Lightning,
Big part of the equation is the 2.5xs has a 3.0 litre tuner and exhaust set up. So it makes total sense that you are getting more slip with that exhaust scenario. Bottom line is you need more blades to hold the water to get more straight line push. Your powerhead is 2.5 but that is as far as that goes,how it comes out of the gearcase and mid is different. You are more than welcome to call me and we can work on getting you squared away, you are obligated to BUY NOTHING so it is win win. Would love to help 330-425-3629 M-F 9-5.
TBuck
P.S. All good info on replies!!!!! Won't find that too many places.